I am going to try to keep my opinion on this short and sweet because at this point, everybody and their mother has weighed in on it. As many of you probably know, at the recent Pro Tour Shadows Over Innistrad, Wizards dropped a bombshell on the professional community (check it out here). They were cutting the appearance fees for all Platinum Pros by over 90% next year. Their justification for this was that they were funneling that money into the prize pool for the World Championship creating a $500,000 prize pool for next year’s tournament.
I personally think it is a great idea to raise the stakes in professional magic. One of the issues with magic is that the premier level events just pale in comparison to any e-sports event. League of Legends and even Hearthstone sell out venue as people watch professionals battle it out for prize pools north of $1,000,000. Magic has nothing that comes close to this, our “premier events” have a prize pool that is barely tenth of what most e-sports offer.
However, cutting the professional appearance fee was not the way to go about this. Players have been grinding out pro-points for the past year to get the coveted title of Platinum. Wizards has essentially ripped the rug out from under them. Pros dedicated the time under the assumption that X would be the reward. However, Wizards all of sudden went back on this.
Wizards was pretty quick to respond to the criticism about these awful changes, returning the appearance fee to normal next year and reevaluating the changes in the meantime. However, I think this announcement did something a lot more than make some pros upset. Wizards of the Coast lost the trust of the million of players that they have. This attempted announcement essentially said that Wizards does not have to keep their promises to players and more importantly will do so without getting our opinions.
Returning the appearance fees was the first step in a long uphill battle to regain our trust. A word of caution to you Wizards, we care about our game deeply, please don’t try to pull a quick on us again, or you will lose us.